This morning there was a beautiful hoarfrost sparkling on the rooftops and limning the trees and shining diamonds all along the green grass and the skies were painted all shades of tangerine-lemon-marmalade by the sunrise. It was stunningly gorgeous. And for a short while, the sparkly white of the hoarfrost let me pretend to myself that it was a seasonally appropriate dusting of snow and that my heart wouldn't be breaking for how we have fucked over the planet given it's going to be in the 60s again this coming week.... In the second week of November.... In Wisconsin....
At least it should be nice enough for once last picnic (maybe?) and to sit out watch the stars afterward when Crissy and I go see Proof, our last APT play of the 2023 season, on Weds. 15. (They always do one late play in late Oct/early Nov in the indoor theatre, The Touchstone, after the season closes for the year.) But my heart will be sad that the wheel of the year is so fucked up and it will be a bit of a sad sitting heavy upon me until the snow falls and sticks. Which right now doesn't look like it's in our forecast at all before I head out a month from now to visit my sister's family in Seattle area. (long forecast says there may not be a snow that sticks until after I get back at the end of December. In Wisconsin.)
~*~*~*~
So. I was thinking about it this morning. And.
The thought I need to give up Eric this lifetime for his sake, all it's ever done for me is throw me into the hollows like I get when grieving the death of a loved one. That's it. And that's not so much an emotion, neither sorrow nor anger, as it is the absence of all emotions so that you can't drown in the deep sorrow/anger/pain. I named it the hollows as a kid after my grandfather died and I blamed myself because he wouldn't take seriously my warning recurring vision dream and made me promise not to tell anyone else in the family since it would upset them. I called it the hollows when I was nine because it's the place where you're hollowed out of all emotions. The sorrow can't touch you there, but also the good emotions like joy and love can't touch you there. Nothing can touch you there. It's the place where you are hollow and no emotions can reach you.
The thing with the hollows is that it's easy to be stoic while there and give up things that bring you joy when you're not in the hollows because you can't be upset, you're feeling nothing at all. So stoicism, going on without a thing you desire or love, well that's easy because you don't feel the desire or love. I don't know if it's really stoic if you don't feel the loss at all -- it's like asking if doing something is brave when you never felt fear before doing it. If bravery is doing the thing that scares you DESPITE the fear, then is it stoicism if you don't feel anything about what you're going to do without while deciding to let it go? I don't know. But in the hollows is an easy place to do stupidly "stoic" "brave" brutal things because you don't feel anything at all about the consequences of what you're doing because you don't feel anything at all about anything Where your feelings should be is just hollow.
So you see, I've never felt anything about the idea of giving up Eric because there's no place for me in his life and that's how he wants it. Because believing it throws me into the hollows of grieving and every glimmer of hope or changed circumstances that has ever made me reevaluate gives me just this upwelling surging sunrise of joy and wonder to have back something I thought forever lost to me. I don't actually know what emotions I have or would have if I really did lose him entirely have to give him up this life because he didn't want me. And I don't know how vast the hollows of grieving losing him would be, I don't know how long the hollows and their nothingness where my heart should be would last. It's not like you can see to the other side of them while you're in it.
Trying to make myself accept the necessity of letting him go is a process of pushing myself back into the grief mourning place where you feel nothing at all.... Every time. I told you it wasn't healthy for my heart whenever I try to make me do it. That's why.
But. So. I don't ACTUALLY know what I might feel if I ever really did lose him entirely from my life this life because there's no place for me in his. I've never been there. I don't know if I ever can. For all I know, I might just stay in the hollows after that, just stay stuck in the places where the pain/sorrow of grief is so deep that you retreat to feeling nothing because you don't have the strength for feeling those as deep as they cut.
That's part of why I decided it's so dangerous to me to have that particular unexamined premise inside me. Because if I listen to it at all, it pushes me toward the hollows the closer I get to accepting what it says. And the hollows isn't a healthy place to have one's heart. But especially not when it's based on an unfounded unexamined premise that could be you lying to yourself. And lying to yourself in a way that works directly opposed to making real anything your heart truly desires.
Does that make sense? I mean, the hollows might not make sense, not everyone gets that way where they hurt so deep over something that they just lose the capacity to feel anything until the grief/sorrow/pain lessens to a point you can come to terms with feeling it again. I know not everyone reacts that way, but I do. I go to the hollows and I keep putting one foot in front of the other doing the things that have to be done and I keep an eye out for other people I care about who might be hurting to try to ease their burden. Until I can find my way back from the hollows, until the loss/grief/pain is no longer threatening to drown me if I let any of it reach me.
It's a strange thing. The existence of an idea in your head you loathe and don't want to be true but that some part of you keeps insisting you have to face in case it is true.... To have repeated to your own self the lie of a conclusion drawn from the changed circumstances created by the choices of a third party until your mind believes it as an unexamined truth, an obvious certainty you don't have to like but you need to accept, but that your heart so categorically rejects accepting that all attempts to force your heart to believe it cause your heart to completely shut down into the deep mourning mode of the hollows until something comes along to revive it with hope that maybe that conclusion isn't inevitable after all because maybe it's not any damn thing he wants to be true same as you don't want it to be true.
It's a very strange juxtaposition and crossroads between my head/logic and my heart/desire. And the easy and obvious answer is to just reject the idea entirely. But my mind is too well trained in logic and scientific method and so it refuses to reject a hypothesis without evidence that refutes it. Evidence that would refute it is the one thing I can guarantee would yank that motherfucking unexamined premise right out of me because I would have proof it was false. But I don't have any sort of incontrovertible evidence to refute the hypothesis that there's no place for me in Eric's life and I'm no part of the happiness he seeks. And before you tell me that there's no evidence supporting the contradictory hypothesis that he DOES want me as part of his life and I AM a part of the happiness he seeks, don't you see that the very fact I'm not in his life or a part of the happiness he tries to build himself is evidence enough to show that hypothesis has nothing supporting it? Yes there's a difference between what a person WANTS and what a person HAS, but he's made plenty of choices and acted on those choices for what he builds his life and happiness around -- and what of those choices has ever included me? Exactly. So I can't even hold both hypotheses as equally likely based on evidence as some form of neutral.
Still. The realization I had was that it is my truth that my heart doesn't know what it would feel IF it's true the hypothesis I can't seem to reject that there's no place for me in his life and I am no part of the happiness he seeks for himself. Because my heart just retreats to the hollows of deep mourning at anything that makes the hypothesis seem to have evidence proving it true. And in the hollows, I can't feel any damn thing about anything. It's all just a hollow space empty of feelings. So I couldn't tell you what I would feel about it, because just trying to accept it drives me to the hollows where I feel no emotions at all.
And here's the kicker of it. When your heart shuts down from grief, sends you to the hollows where you feel nothing, all that remains to you to guide you is your code of ethics and your empathy. So what do you do when your code of ethics and the logic your head has followed are the source of what is making your heart shut down take you to the hollows? My answer: when your heart is in the hollows so your code of ethics and your empathy are all you have as compass to guide your actions, then you keep listening and believing and acting on the best logic you have and only when you either find your way back from the hollows OR something's sucker punches your compassion is there any chance of breaking through the hold on you. Which is why it's always been compassion when he's suffering that has brought me back to him to give him another chance to prove that insidious logic wrong whenever I listen to it. Without that, I'd just keep following the logic of the conclusions I had accepted deeper and deeper into the hollows.
Because what else are you to do when your heart is out of order until the emotions calm down enough they're not threatening to drown you?
Maybe it's been too long and the opportunities are all used up and it's too little too late, but I'm still going to dig out every last vestige of that unexamined premise and every time any unsupported version of it tries to crop up again I'll dig it out of my brain and my assumptions. Because I don't want it in there having any say in guiding me or my ethics or my choices. Let him desire whatever he desires for his life and his happiness, but it's not for me to assume my own unimportance to him just as it's not for me to assume my own importance to him. That place of waiting in the unknown and unknowable, that's what I am trying to replace the five year old conclusion turned unexamined premise in my beliefs.
P. S. I finished my re-read of the Hunger Games trilogy and either tonight or tomorrow I'll be starting my second read through of The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. I stand by my decision to read it once, re-read the trilogy as it had been years since my last re-read, and then re-read Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes again. After that, I haven't yet figured out what I'll be reading next. We will see what I feel like reading when I get there at some point next week.

