So last night, as part of her stage banter, Aoife was talking about her experience of COVID shutting everything down and being in the states needing to get back to Ireland in the midst of the most surreal St. Patrick's Day season ever back in 2020. And she was talking about how they were in Nashville staying at the house of the banjo player with Alison Krause (Ron is a good friend of theirs) working on some songs because the Nashville Irish fair they were scheduled to play at had been canceled and she said something that I've been turning over in my head since then. She said, "The festival hadn't been cancelled because of COVID. It was cancelled because of the tornado that went through. I swear to youse, it feels like there's always something trying to kill yez while in America." And when we were chatting post show, she brought it up again in the context of some other natural weather event and we started talking about how there's nowhere in America where you're free from the ever present possibility of the earth or the air or the water or wildfires murdering you. But in contrast, Ireland doesn't have atmospheric or tectonic attempts as acts of God to suddenly kill you, "All wes have is rain, plenty of it, but all gentle like. Just rain."
But the thing is, with Uvalde so fresh in my mind, I knew she was talking about the weather trying to kill people here but in my mind it was also an acknowledgement that as a foreign traveller here you accept the possibility of being gunned down anywhere and everywhere and you learn to live with that fatalism in your every day lives. That was my layered understanding of her words, she was talking purely weather trying to kill people.
And it made me consider.... We talk about how it's the money and lobbies corrupting politicians but money and power corrupt the system in all nations and bureaucracies around the world in all times. If it were only money and manufacturing lobbyists, the rest of the world would have the same civilian gun violence issues. If it were the entertainment industry desensitization, be it films or TV or video games, the problem would be global because the entertainment industry is global and everyone in the modern world has those Ender simulacra of violence fed into their brains. We talk about how the American psyche is built on systems of oppression and white supremacy and misogyny and center this in our discussion of the uniquely American issues surrounding gun violence and ownership and availability -- all of which is true. But there are other nations and other places that have been built on such evil ideas becoming accepted societal norms. And they have been able to brick by brick start the process of deconstructing and resolving things and healing so that the past is a tool to reshape a better future than the wrongs that came before.
In America, that doesn't happen. We have aspirational times of wanting it and even dedicated individuals working towards it, but never the sustained focus to create lasting changes to the philosophical underpinnings and the framing of laws to heal these things.
And Aoife's comment about the tornado got me thinking: what if the uniquely American danse macabre combination of defensive fear and fatalism isn't because of the corrupting influence of money and industry lobbyists or something cursed by the toxic mix of European colonialism and religious fundamentalism (after all look at New Zealand and Canada) and the genocides and slavery of the past... What if it's because at a fundamental root psychological level Americans have lived and continue to live every day as if it's a throw of the dice that an act of God might try to kill you that day - so you learn to live and find joy under the shadow of the terror that the very earth and air keep omnipresent as potential. And so the things we could do something to mitigate and make better, the things other people in other nations do take actions on refuse to accept as inevitable, we simply don't because it's so deeply ingrained in us living reactively with the terror that at any moment a tornado or earthquake or hurricane or wildfire or deep snowfall or extreme heat or extreme cold or drought or floods could destroy your life and/or everything you created/value. It makes us willfully blind to the ways we can protect the most vulnerable and defend against the evils in humanity getting out of hand because we spend every moment of our lives from our youngest hours learning how to prepare best possible defense plans and then taking immediate steps for the practical rebuilding after the catastrophe and just go about our daily lives activities with that fear and fatalism as if that's normal. But never to minimize the frequency or intensity of it's occurring, just to train ourselves for how best to react WHEN it occurs.
And the fear tells you to do everything you can to protect yourself - whether it's having a basement for tornadoes or the theory that you too can be a good guy with a gun vigilante hero so long as you have as much access to the guns as bad guys with a gun. And the fatalism tells you to accept that this was tragic and horrific and we did everything we could to make sure people have tornado sirens and basements but still deaths happened and lives were ruined and now we rebuild. We planned the defenses of the schools/churches and trained the staff hired those to mitigate harm and held drills so we would know the steps to take if the emergency happened here.....
Americans react to man-made problems and societal illness catastrophes the same way we react to tornadoes/hurricanes/wildfires. And I wonder how much of the way Americans handle gun violence issues and racially motivated lynchings and police brutality is directly due to their psychological programming and philosophical nihilism instilled at a very young age about death by random act of God due to the ways the geography of this landmass is always trying to kill you in some fashion while you just go about your daily life in the shadows of that existential threat.
It's just something I've been thinking about and contemplating today as a more primal root cause philosophical distinction compared to other nations for why Americans live the way they do with the gun violence issue. And it makes me question if gun violence and white supremacy as a control issue can ever be unpacked so something better and more holistic a society can be built without facing the philosophical dilemmas of living in chronic catastrophe reactionary mode and trying to find something you can control when you live from your youngest possible age under the existential threat that something is always trying to kill you in America.
It's not an answer. And i don't have an answer for how to psychologically unpack and ask the questions to shift this at a fundamental framework level for engaging with reality. I have some ideas but I don't have answers. Just questions and connections and this train of thought about natural catastrophes creating a framework of accepting existential threats as a daily inevitability is something I'm pursuing today to try to understand and answer the question the Sky News reporter asked Ted Cruz about why brutal gun violence and school shootings are a uniquely American exceptionalism....(obviously Ted Cruz lacks the intellectual depth and philosophizing temperament to question the fact America is a society steeped in the terror of existential dread of things we accept are beyond our control to stop or prevent, where all anyone can do is prepare, endure, and rebuild. And that it is part of the foundation cornerstones of both our great source of strength in our resourceful scrappiness and also the most damning weaknesses of nihilism and cultural inaction that harms the most vulnerable.)
Anyway. I'm going to plug my phone in now since it's at 4% battery life. And then I'm going to fold my cleaning rags torn up of scraps of old shirts because the dryer chimed during my writing that last paragraph. (I reuse and repurpose as much as possible rather than buy new. Especially for storage and cleaning or instead of using disposable versions. Other than for company, why buy new cloth with the intention of destroying it making it dirty and stained? Including tearing apart and rag binning old shirts. I also save the drippings and ends of candles and re melt them with new wicks of they can be salvaged. Past lives of accumulated habits of thrift and using every bit of things rather than wasting it.) And then after moving along the laundry I'm going to drink coffee and read and let my mind continue to ponder in the background this new theory about America's over preparedness but paralysis of proactive actions in preventable acts of human-mediated disasters due to living in perpetual existential dread that the land/air/water itself is going to try to kill you.












